COMMENT: FROM WISE WOMEN TO WITCHES

           It's  Halloween and I got  tell you this is an embarrassing time to be associated with Christianity. I especially think about witches and how the Church maligned and slandered their good name.  How is it that those who were once so highly regarded as the wise women of the community came to be identified with all that was evil and vile.  Are you familiar with the story ?  The History Channel did an excellent synopsis of this transformation  this week and it merits repeating for those who missed it. 

Basically this transformation took place over several thousand years. Initially what we would call witches were the priestesses of female, earth  deities. Whether called Ashura or Isis or a number of other names, these goddesses were attended to by women who conducted rituals, healed the sick, and midwifed the deliveries of pregnant women. They were wise and powerful  and dealt with the mysteries of life with magic.  At about  3000 BCE, bellicose  Indo- European tribes invaded the west taking over and transforming peaceful  matriarchal societies into warrior based, male dominated cultures. These tribes worshipped  warrior, male Gods. Thus the place of the Earth goddesses and their priestesses was lowered. 

Worse Judaism's YHWH was jealous of and  antagonistic to their practices and condemned both witchcraft and its practitioners.  Nonetheless this did  not stop Hebrew kings to turning to them in their hour of need  (see Samuel 28.7) 

The most significant blow to witches came in the 15 th century during in the midst of the Black Plague. It is hard to imagine such a calamity which killed more than thirty percent of the people in western Europe. Without science to understand what was happening or effective  medicine to combat it, people panicked and the Church seized upon this crisis to declare that its strongest rival , was responsible. For the first time witches were linking with the Devil who was understood as the ultimate source of the scourge. 

The inquisition was begun to seek out and destroy those who were suspected to be in league with Satan and thereby ending the plague.  In what was  perhaps the most misogynist book ever written, Maleus Malefacorium, provided a hand book for  investigators  to determine who were witches. This text concocted by two monks, Springer and Kramer was pure propaganda.  It claimed that  women were by their nature vulnerable to the Devil due to their lustful nature.  Wise women never worshipped the devil much less had sex with him. Nonetheless a terrified and hysterical continent was willing to believe that the people they had formerly trusted and turned to was now the source of their malady.   It is difficult to accept but it is true that  due to the Church's persecution  and torture  between 60,000 and 300,000 completely innocent women were put to death  in less than 200 years. 

The third development which is so disturbing, involves us . The Salem witch  trials is a shameful tale. Indeed, for in addition furthering the lies about witches, the trials took religious hysteria and persecution to a new level.  Religious intolerance  became a political weapon.  Indeed all of the self righteous concern for morality and fighting the devil was in fact a way of destroying one's political enemies. Everyone of the accusers was on one side of a local  political struggle and everyone of the defendants were on the other. It is interesting that the end of the the trials came abruptly  the same day the wife of the governor of Massachusetts was accused. 

The history is humbling and disturbing. While it is painful to realize how  the church has been  unable to accept and  honor the  gifts of women differences, it is horrifying  to realize the lengths it has gone to to destroy their very existence. 

We live in an age of science and witches are no longer seen as a serious threat to anything. If anything Wicca represents an ecologically responsible group. Nonetheless the importance of valuing tolerance and celebrating diversity need to be constantly remembered.

Rev. Michael Heath, Fayetteville NY - 10/28/99


Back to Past Articles

Back to Main Page